Choosing the wrong fulfilment partner can cost you customers, damage your brand, and create operational headaches that take months to unpick. Here's how to get the decision right the first time.
Your fulfilment partner is, in effect, the last touchpoint between your brand and your customer. They pack the box, choose the carrier, and determine whether the parcel arrives on time and in good condition. A poor experience at this stage — damaged goods, wrong items, slow delivery — reflects on you, not them.
Switching fulfilment providers is also painful. Moving stock, reconnecting integrations, updating carrier accounts — it typically takes weeks and causes disruption. Getting it right first time is worth the effort.
Where your 3PL warehouse is located directly affects your delivery times and costs. If most of your customers are in Ireland, a facility based in the Republic of Ireland gives you the fastest domestic delivery times and avoids the complexity of cross-border shipping on every order.
If you're targeting the UK market heavily, a provider with a UK operation (or a strong relationship with UK carriers) makes more sense. Some providers have multi-location networks — useful if your customer base is genuinely split across multiple countries.
The headline rate per order is only part of the story. Fulfilment pricing typically involves several components, and the providers who look cheapest on paper sometimes have the most expensive hidden fees.
Ask every prospective partner for a full breakdown of:
Some providers charge a minimum monthly fee regardless of order volume. If you're just starting out or have seasonal peaks and troughs, this can make a low-volume month unexpectedly expensive.
Your store and your fulfilment provider need to communicate seamlessly. When a customer places an order, the fulfilment system should receive it automatically, without you manually forwarding anything.
Check which platforms and marketplaces your prospective partner integrates with:
Also ask about the quality of their warehouse management system (WMS). Can you log in and see your stock levels in real time? Can you view order statuses and tracking numbers? Can you pull reports? Poor visibility creates anxiety and wastes your time chasing updates.
One of the main reasons to use a 3PL is access to better shipping rates. An established fulfilment provider ships thousands of parcels per week and negotiates volume rates with carriers that individual businesses can't access.
Ask which carriers they work with, and whether they pass those rates through to you transparently. Some providers mark up carrier rates significantly — this isn't necessarily wrong, but you should know what you're paying.
For Irish businesses, the main carriers to ask about are An Post, DPD Ireland, and DHL. For UK and European shipping, ask about their relationships with Evri, DPD UK, and DHL Express.
When something goes wrong — a damaged shipment, a missing order, a customer complaint — how quickly can you get a response? This is where the difference between providers becomes most apparent.
What is your SLA for responding to queries? Do I have a named contact for my account? What happens if an order is delayed or lost? How do you handle peak periods like Black Friday?
Pay attention to how quickly and clearly they respond to your initial enquiry. A provider that takes three days to reply to a sales enquiry will likely take three days to reply when you have an urgent problem.
Be wary of providers who insist on long minimum contract terms upfront — 12 or 24 months — before you've had a chance to test the service. The logistics industry has a strong incentive to lock in clients because switching is expensive, but that incentive doesn't always align with your interests.
Look for providers who are willing to start on shorter terms, or who offer a trial period. A provider who is confident in their service doesn't need to trap you in a contract.
Work through these before committing to any provider. Click each item as you complete it.
We'll give you straight answers to all of the above — including the questions where our service isn't the right fit for you.
Make an enquiry →